Islanders cell phones began lighting up early Monday morning as word of coach Ted Nolan’s ouster spread quickly. General manager Garth Snow called several key players to deliver the news personally and offer an explanation.
While most expressed some degree of surprise, captain Bill Guerin didn’t pretend that the obvious rift between the GM and coach didn’t affect the team. “It’s not a real shock to me,” Guerin said. “There was no secret the two sides just weren’t seeing eye-to-eye during the year and over the summer.
“I definitely think it became a distraction. Guys read papers; guys hear what’s going on. We just kind of wondered what was going on and if it was going to resolve itself. So, it has, and you move on.”
From a practical standpoint, Guerin said a coaching change and Snow’s emphasis on giving more ice time to young players shouldn’t have a major impact on the Islanders. “We’ve all been in many different types of situations before, including coaching changes and prospects coming in,” Guerin said. “It’s nothing anybody on our team hasn’t seen before.”
Mike Sillinger had a more sympathetic reaction than Guerin, who only spent one difficult season under Nolan. When the Islanders defied low expectations during Nolan’s first season and made the playoffs, Sillinger was one of the veterans who enjoyed career seasons and reveled in the trust the coach placed in them.
“Snowy called me and told me what happened,” Sillinger said. “Quite frankly, I don’t know that there was any kind of tug-of-war. I didn’t spend the last half of the season with the guys because of my [hip] injury. The year before, we made the playoffs, and Ted did a great job. Obviously, this year we had a bunch of injuries.
“Garth told me they had philosophical differences. So be it. That’s his decision. It’s really unfortunate. Ted and I had a great relationship. I enjoyed playing for him. I guess you move on.”
Sillinger’s final game last season came on Jan. 24 in Boston, where the Islanders lost just before the All-Star break to fall from seventh to eighth in the Eastern Conference standings. As it turned out, that was the beginning of their slide out of playoff position.
“Players play, coaches coach and managers manage,” Sillinger said. “That’s their decision, and it’s really unfortunate. I’m not going to say a bad thing about anybody or the situation. My relationship with Ted was a good one. We had kind of a special year the first year together, and this last year was a terrible year. It’ always the coach’s fault, right? Someone always gets blamed.”
Although the 37-year-old center might see his role diminish somewhat as he fights to come back from hip surgery, Sillinger said the Islanders can use an injection of youth. “I still think we have the foundation of our team, we have good core guys,” Sillinger said of the veteran leaders. “Now what you need is the young guys to step up and play big roles, play on the power play, play in important situations, play on the top lines. I think we have some young guys that are capable of doing that.”
Goaltender Rick DiPietro emphasized that same theme, saying, “You need to develop your talent in-house and have good drafts, and you need young players to step up and play big roles on your team. You see teams that have been successful, and they have a great young nucleus and some veteran guys around to lead. We’re making good steps to get to that point. We have some exciting guys coming up with Kyle [Okposo] and Blake Comeau, and Jeff Tambellini will get a chance to step in and play a big role on this team.”
DiPietro was among the players who had an edgy relationship with Nolan, who benched the goaltender for a key Rangers game in early March and sometimes indicated a lack of faith in the franchise player. At the same time, DiPietro often expressed a desire for the Isles to play a tighter, more basic defense than the system Nolan used.
“I’m sure anyone will agree that, when we were successful, we played smart, defensive hockey,” DiPietro said. “When we play against New Jersey, we’re world-beaters. We get away from that, and things didn’t go well. The less we went in the penalty box, the better we played defensively, and the more simple we played, the better the result was.”
That was part of the reason Snow wanted Nolan out. The Isles were one of the few teams in the league playing a 1-3-1 system, if not the only one. In that setup, one defenseman mirrors the opposing center in the Isles’ zone, placing more responsibility on the wingers to stay on their man coming back.
“For it to work, everyone had to be on the same page,” defenseman Brendan Witt said. “I don’t think it was a hard system to pick up on. As a winger, you had to be very responsible, more than in any other system definitely.”
In Snow’s view, that style of defense is more suited to a team like Stanley Cup champion Detroit, which has an explosive offense and the ability to play a more wide-open game. But the Isles were more effective when they played similar to the Devils’ conservative style.
Still, Witt acknowledged the Islanders were successful playing the same 1-3-1 system in Nolan’s first season. Despite the apparent strains between the coach and general manager, Witt expected to see Nolan behind the bench at least at the beginning of the coming season.
“I was shocked,” Witt said of the coach’s departure. “I didn’t even know there were bad feelings still. That is part of the business, but I would have thought he’d be coaching us this year. If we started bad or struggled, then, management would have decided to do what most managements do when you’re struggling early in the year.”
But Snow decided to act before the Islanders reached that point. And so, they move on.