A RISK WORTH TAKING
It’s been a long day of telephone calls, teleconferences, checking the internet, transcribing interviews and, finally, writing the two stories about Ryan Smyth’s arrival as an Islander that will appear in Newsday Thursday morning. I was expecting to hear from Ryan around 5 p.m. or so and had long since given up hope, figuring it was a rough travel day for him, not to mention an obviously emotional separation from Edmonton if you have seen his farewell news conference on tsn.ca.
Just as I finished typing up notes from an interview with coach Ted Nolan around 7:30 p.m. and was preparing to write my main story, the phone rang. The voice on the other end asked for “Gary” Logan, a common mistake people make with my name. It was Smyth calling from the airport in Minneapolis, where he was changing planes for a later flight to New York. He apologized, an unnecessary but very thoughtful gesture, and said his agent, Don Meehan, misunderstood my name when he passed on the message.
Not wanting to take up too much of Ryan’s time with a flight to catch, I zipped through a quick interview that was pleasantly upbeat, considering the sudden transition he’s making. We got off the phone, and I called the office to change gears and make the Smyth interview the main story. All of which, I hope, explains why this blog is late-arriving tonight.
Not surprisingly, neither Smyth nor Meehan wanted to discuss coming contract negotiations with the Islanders, who could wind up just renting him for their playoff push and the postseason if they qualify. Smyth said he was “drained” by negotiations with the Oilers, and Meehan said it’s “premature” to talk about signing with the Isles.
No doubt, four months until the July 1 free-agent period opens is plenty of time to reach an agreement if Smyth is so inclined. The process of getting to know each other starts Thursday when Smyth skates with the team in the morning before playing on a line with Jason Blake and probably Randy Robitaille against St. Louis. Meehan will be here for the meet and greet along with several members of his law firm.
Smyth’s agent said his only contact with owner Charles Wang and general manager Garth Snow had been to discuss travel arrangements. When I asked if Smyth would sign if the Islanders meet his asking price, Meehan said, “We haven’t even had a discussion. We’ve gone through a very difficult time, and we haven’t even approached that process other than Ryan feeling he really wants to contribute and get the Islanders into the playoffs.”
As Snow indicated when he announced the trade, that really is the first order of business. The Islanders have 19 games to see if Smyth can make a difference in their locker room and in front of the net on the power play. He helped lead eighth-seeded Edmonton to Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Finals last season, and the way the Islanders have played throughout their 11-2-4 streak, you’ve got to believe they are as much, if not more, of a threat than the Oilers were this time last season.
In fact, their progress to this point is what convinced Nolan to push for the deal despite the cost of former first-round picks Robert Nilsson and Ryan O’Marra plus this years’ No. 1 pick. Smyth’s toughness and leadership are renowned north of the border, where he is known as “Captain Canada” because he has been on so many national teams. During the Oilers’ playoff run last year, Smith suffered an incident in which he lost most of his teeth, but he rejected oral surgery until after the season, got stitched up and didn’t miss a game.
New Islanders defenseman Marc-Andre Bergeron also was acquired from Edmonton and is good friends with Smyth. Describing the power forward’s impact in the locker room, Bergeron said, “Ryan is more of an active role. He’s able to take a lot on his shoulders. The main thing is he really finds a way to answer. I’ve seen him taking some heat, and he’s able to answer back the next period or getting that big goal. It’s something that not too many players in any sport are capable of doing.”
Nolan, Snow and, yes, former GM Neil Smith, built this Islanders team around character and grit, and Smyth is the epitome of what the coach wants from future Islanders. Ever since Snow became GM, he and the rest of the scouting staff focused on getting a handle on the prospects in the organization and making determinations about their value because he wanted to be prepared for a situation like the one he faced at the trade deadline and try to avoid the mistakes of the past in terms of giving up too soon on a good prospect.
Does Nilsson have skill. Yes. People who have played with and against him have expressed great admiration for his skill level. But the question is whether he competes the way Nolan is going to require in the future. Apparently, it didn’t look that way at Bridgeport. O’Marra was a solid prospect, but he certainly hasn’t been dominant as a senior player with Saginaw in the OHL. Is he better than Blake Comeau will be? Sean Bergenheim?
Kyle Okposo is the Islanders’ only first-round pick since Nolan was hired, and he wasn’t going anywhere no matter what was offered. He fits the future mold. And in a league where there will be a high turnover rate in the free agent market every summer, Nolan is confident of finding other players who will fit the mold and who will want to come to Long Island once they see the kind of team he is building.
When you have a shot to gamble on a Ryan Smyth and add him to a team that has good goaltending in Rick DiPietro and the will to battle every single night, it’s a risk worth taking.
“We talk about speed, and we talk about skill a lot,” Nolan said. “But the thing we have to include in that mix is how hard a kid competes, how hard they work and their competitive level. And Ryan Smyth, when he was 18 years old, those are the qualities he demonstrated. And he’s done it through his whole career.
“So, it’s nice to have people who can play, but I always say, ‘My sister could play.’ We want people who know how to win and want to win and compete and love to play the game. That’s the whole environment we’re trying to create, and Garth and I have spoken a number of occasions on that along with Charles. We’re just starting. Hopefully, we have a long ways to go here and a long tenure and we keep building it and get stronger and better.”