By Mike Casey
After last night’s 5-2 drubbing at the hands of the Rangers, it’s clear that the Islanders are in a sharp downturn. Not a Wayne Gretzky, 110-point season downturn. I’m talking about a Rick DiPietro 3.55-goals against average season.
I know plenty of Islanders fans, and I don't think there is one out there who would disagree with this statement: It’s time for a total destruction of their current roster. Think Indepedence Day meets Death Star.
Of course, not much of the stuff I'm about to suggest has a legitimate chance to happen, and I am only taking the Islanders' future into account... But what the hell -- isn’t this what blogs are for? First let’s cover...
THE UNTOUCHABLES
Rick DiPietro: “Agggh!” you say. “Why would you want to make a guy with an .890 save percentage and an expiring one-year contract untouchable?” Let me clarify: I don’t want to make him untouchable. I just have to.
The Islanders have too much symbolism invested in the 24-year-old goaltender to even consider letting him loose. To do so would be to admit that Mike Milbury’s 2000 trade of Roberto Luongo for Oleg Kvasha and Mark Parrish was a tremendous miscalculation. (As if that weren't already true.)
Like it or not, the Islanders bought big into DiPietro’s stock when they drafted him No. 1 overall in 2000. And now that another player from that same draft – Henrik Lundqvist, selected 205th – is playing so well for the Rangers, the Islanders are, as we say in poker, “pot committed” to DiPietro’s future. As much as they might like to deal him away for draft picks and hope a better goalie comes along, they’ve got to ride out the rough spots, no matter what.
Alexei Yashin: Islanders fans, please get this through your heads: The Islanders are not going to trade Alexei Yashin. Not even if they find out Carol Alt has blackmail material on the entire front office, including Sparky the dragon and most of the Ice Girls. They simply cannot trade him.
Yashin is making $7.6 million per season for the next five seasons. You simply don’t move that kind of cash without a mob connection and an “Office Space”-like plot involving computers and a guy named Samir. Yashin may be the most overpaid player in the NHL, but once again, Islanders fans, I cannot help you here. I may be brilliant, but I am not God.
Jason Blake: Possibly the best trade Mike Milbury ever made was grabbing this lunatic winger from the Los Angeles Kings for a fifth-round draft pick. I mean 'lunatic' in the best possible way here.
Blake represents everything the Islanders should aspire to be in the future, from his tireless hustle to his gritty board work, to his ability to score and kill penalties.
If the Islanders do fall out of the playoff race, teams will come a-knocking, wondering they can pry Blake and his reasonable $1.558 million salary from their despondent clutches. But unless they're offered Todd Bertuzzi, Dany Heatley, or Bryan McCabe for him, I say no deal. If DiPietro and Yashin must be more cornerstones, I can at least have Blake as my template.
TRADING BLOCK:
Mark Parrish is the best, most consistent player on the Islanders. Dealing him at the trade deadline could bring a bounty of draft picks, which could later be used to reverse the Islanders’ usual scenario of front-office members kicking themselves for letting young talent get away.
Parrish is 29 and still in the prime of his career. But his game doesn’t quite fit into the mold I’d like my first-line winger to have. Maybe the Isles could create some kind of package – possibly including Shawn Bates – that would yield them a promising young forward like Edmonton’s Ales Hemsky or the Kings’ Alexander Frolov. Anaheim’s Joffrey Lupul could be had for a lesser price. (Are you liking how I just throw out names without having any idea whether their teams would be willing to trade them? Good times.)
Miroslav Satan: By now, most teams realize they’re taking a bit of a gamble on this guy. He could be an excellent fit on a team desperate for offense. But he could also be a terrible fit on a team that plays a gritty, defense-first style. Quagmire.
My theory is, find that team desperate for offense, and pounce like paparazzi on a Tara Reid dress mishap.
Montreal is a team that might fit the bill nicely. They’ve got the framework of a decent team, but are 21st in the league in goal scoring. They might like a little extra offense, even if it costs them, say, young defenseman and East Islip native Mike Komisarek, plus a fourth-round draft pick.
The only problem is Miro’s price tag. Poorer Canadian teams will not be so willing to take on Satan’s $4 million-per-year salary, so I might have to eat some more of his contract and keep him alongside Yashin for another year for the sake of appearances.
Trent Hunter: If there is one thing general managers love, it is power forwards who score 20 goals in their rookie season. Hunter (10 goals this year) might land me a dependable third-line center, like Washington’s Brian Sutherby, plus a fourth round draft pick. We’re stockpiling draft picks here, people.
Arron Asham: Maybe it's just me, but I don't think Asham has ever been as good as some people think, and I can’t figure out for the life of me why the Islanders insist on giving him as much ice time as they do.
His stock is as high as it’ll ever be. Let’s send him and one of those fourth round picks to Toronto for defenseman Carlo Coliacovo. He can be a future power play quarterback and he's not a bad defender. Now we’re having some fun.
RECAP SO FAR:
I’ve got DiPietro, Yashin, Blake, Hemsky, Sutherby, Komisarek, and Coliacovo, plus an extra fourth round draft pick. I’ve still got Mike York, Brent Sopel, Alexei Zhitnik, Garth Snow, Radek Martinek, Chris Campoli, Brad Lukowich and Eric Godard kicking around.
NOW WHAT?
Sopel ($2.4M) and Zhitnik ($3.5M) are both tough to move because of their big, newly-signed contracts. But GMs also have a weakness for ‘puck-moving defensemen,’ which means I might be able to pawn one or both of them off, as long as I pick up a bad contract in return.
Or how about I trade both of them for Chicago’s Adrian Aucoin ($4.0M, also newly-signed) and Duncan Keith (15 points, 22 years old). I can score a few points with the fans by bringing back Aucoin, and add a good all-around defenseman to an up-and-coming blueline.
So now I have Aucoin, Keith, Komisarek, Coliacovo, Campoli, Martinek, and Lukowich on defense. Not a bad group. But I could use one more veteran with a good presence.
How about the Rangers' Jason Strudwick? The guy has proven to be an extremely valuable locker-room influence, as well as a great teammate and a worthy stay-at-home defenseman. He's a free agent after this season, and it would be worth grabbing him for the added value of sticking it to the Boys in Blue.
Now that my defense is more or less settled, I need to help my forwards.
Here’s where I make my big splash.
THE BIG ONES
I package Martinek, York, Lukowich and a 2nd round draft pick and make a run at San Jose wingers Jonathan Cheechoo (31 goals this season, 25 years old) and Milan Michalek (6th overall pick in 2003). I get a big upgrade in offense and remove some of the surplus defenders from my roster. York and Martinek are unrestricted free agents this summer anyway.
Speaking of free agents, I need to make a splash there, too. So I sign the top free agent wing on the market: New Jersey's Patrik Elias. And I get Ed Jovanovski from Vancouver, to complete my defensive corps.
RECAPPING THE DEFENSE:
My defense is complete. I've got Aucoin, Jovanovski, Komisarek, Campoli, Coliacovo, Strudwick, and Keith. A good mix of offense and defense, youngsters and veterans. Now let's round out the rest:
RECAPPING THE FORWARDS:
Still a bit of work to do. I've got Elias, Yashin, Cheechoo, Sutherby, Hemsky, and Blake to be a good top six. Actually, let's finally give youngster Robert Nilsson a chance to earn big minutes on the second line and bump Sutherby to the third line. Now I just need to fill out the...
ODDS & ENDS
First, I deal my previously-acquired fourth-round pick for Ottawa enforcer Chris Neil. Bye-bye, Eric Godard.
I sign free agent pest/penalty killer P.J. Axelsson, and face-off wizard Yanic Perreault. Depending on price, I may also sign Buffalo's Mike Grier or Columbus' Trevor Letowski for some grit.
Garth Snow walks and Wade Dubielewicz becomes my full-time backup. And that's that!
THE TEAM
Here are you 2006-07 New York Islanders!
1st line: Elias-Yashin-Cheechoo
2nd line: Nilsson-Blake-Hemsky
3rd line: Michalek-Sutherby-Grier
4th line: Axelsson-Perreault-Neil
Pairing 1: Aucoin/Campoli
Pairing 2: Coliacovo/Jovanovski
Pairing 3: Keith, Strudwick, Komisarek all available
Penalty killers: Blake, Sutherby, Grier, Perreault, Axelsson, Cheechoo
Power play quarterbacks: Aucoin, Campoli, Coliacovo
Goaltenders: DiPietro and Dubielewicz
Think I'm nuts? E-mail me and let me know just how crazy I am.
Check out hockeytraderumors.com's unofficial list of 2006 free agents for a little help. Just bear in mind, this is all in good fun!