Main

Reviews Archives

March 31, 2008

‘Stop-Loss’: An inconvenient untruth

If you’ve seen the trailers for “Stop-Loss,” there’s a particularly memorable Ryan Phillippe quote: “I honored my contract, and I expect the army to do the same.”

Only one problem: The quote is nowhere in the film.

And there seems to be good reason for that. Soldiers taking to the Internet, including on the movie’s IMDB.com page, point out that a standard enlistment contract is for eight years — and whatever is not served in the active military will be served as a reserve.

Although the terminology isn’t there, “stop-loss” is clearly in the contract, too: “In a time of war or national emergency declared by the Congress, I may be required to serve on active duty for the entire period of the war … ,” the contract says. (Although, Phillippe's character does argue that President Bush has declared the war is over.)

Check out section 10 of the contract here.

It’s no wonder the Phillippe quote found its way on to the cutting room floor. But how did it ever make it into the trailers in the first place?

Was writer and director Kimberly Peirce in such a rush to make a political statement that she didn’t bother to read an enlistment contract until just prior to the film’s release? Or did she think her audience was too ignorant to know the truth or too lazy to find out?

With or without the quote, knowing how clear the contract is, it waters down, if not completely destroys, any sort of message Peirce was trying to make about a solider who was dumbfounded that he was being sent back to Iraq. He obviously never read his contract.
— Ryan Chatelain


March 27, 2008

Bardot flick a tribute to her fine physique

contempt.jpg

My childhood friend and I checked out the classic 1963 Brigitte Bardot film “Contempt” at the Film Forum on Wednesday night. I myself am not a big fan of French cinema, but I love things French and find their style irresistible.

I went in clueless and with an open mind. Shortly after finding our seats a women with big hair had positioned herself in front of my friend. After a chuckle we decided to relocate but realized the theater was now packed to capacity — and with mostly men — curious indeed. I soon found out why…

“Contempt” stars the blonde bombshell Bardot, Michel Piccoli and Jack Palance. Piccoli plays a screenwriter married to Bardot. Their marriage is clearly on the rocks as soon as Piccoli accepts a writing job from producer Palance, who plays “an ugly American” with great zeal. It goes something like this — Bardot pouts, Piccoli wants to know why and Palance stomps around like a peacock glaring at Bardot and berating those around him.

But the plot really is secondary to Bardot’s well, how can I put this delicately, her perfectly shaped derriere. Director Jean-Luc Godard spends countless frames on it, shooting it from all angles in various Italian locals — Capri is stunning with and without Bardot’s bootylicous bod. The movie was shot in Cinemascope — Godard takes his time showcasing Italy with grand slow pans. I found the music overpowering and repetitive. Was Jean-Luc trying to get a point across or simply could only afford one movement? “Maybe it’s a French thing,” my friend suggested.

"Contempt" is playing through Thursday at the Film Forum, Houston Street, west of 6th Ave. Showtimes: 1:30, 3:30, 5:30, 7:30, 9:30.

— Peggy Mihelich

February 29, 2008

Weekend's Best Bet: Chop Shop

anne2.jpg
("The Other Boleyn Girl")

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help:

Chop Shop
Once called a "euphemism for blight" by Mayor Bloomberg, Willets Point, Queens, is for all intents and purposes the star of Ramin Bahrani's "Chop Shop." Nicknamed the "Iron Triangle" for its high density of junkyards and auto shops, this 61-acre neighborhood in the shadow of Shea Stadium is, in real estate terms, an eyesore that many mayors (including Bloomberg) have tried to earmark for redevelopment. Read more...

The Other Boleyn Girl
Heaving bosom alert! This story of Anne Boleyn's rise from the ranks of minor nobility and her subsequent fall to the chopping block is a sweeping Tudor soap opera, from the bethrothals and betrayals to the chin-stroking villain.

Natalie Portman plays Anne, the doomed coquette, with Scarlett Johansson as her plain sister, Mary. (In Hollywood, "plain" is conveyed by denuding a face of all makeup.) Read more...

AP Photo/Columbia Pictures

February 15, 2008

Weekend's best bet: The Year My Parents Went on Vacation

35629780.gif

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help:

The Year My Parents Went on Vacation
In this sweet little coming-of-age tale, set in Sao Paulo in 1970, "vacation" is a euphemism for political exile. On the run from a persecuting government, a subversive left-wing couple drops their 12-year-old son, Mauro (Michel Joelsas), off at Grandpa's doorstep before they go into hiding.Read more...

Jumper
With the same composer and (one-time) director from the Jason Bourne trilogy, "Jumper" often feels like a poor man's Bourne movie. A really, really impoverished, poor man's version about a guy being chased around the world. Read more...

AP Photo from The Year My Parents Went on Vacation

February 8, 2008

Weekend's best bet: Vince Vaughn's Wild West Comedy Show

vince0208.jpg

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help:

Vince Vaughn's Wild West Comedy Show
The title says it all: a 30-day, 30-show comedy tour hosted by Vince Vaughn, starting in L.A. and ending in Chicago by way of Bakersfield, Nashville, Birmingham and a couple dozen other cities in middle America. There's not much of a rootin', tootin' feel, but "Vince Vaughn's Wild West Comedy Show" is certainly one of the most amiable movies we've seen so far this year.Read more...

In Bruges
The dialogue in In Bruges--starring Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson as a pair of hitmen sent to Bruges, Belgium, to wait for word on their next assignmen-- is in-your-face, crass and politically incorrect at every turn, and guns and blood-spattering get plenty of screen timeRead more...

AP Photo of Vince Vaughn by Matt Sayles

January 11, 2008

Weekend's best bet: Being Born

born.jpg

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help:

Business of Being Born
It's not the slickest documentary, but "The Business of Being Born" is certainly an earnest, compelling examination of childbirth in America, specifically the manner in which women decide to have babies: at the hospital with a doctor or at home with a midwife. Read more...

First Sunday
Ice Cube's new movie "First Sunday" is not a sequel to the "Friday" movies, but it sure does have the look and feel of a franchise that has long outstayed its welcome.Read more...

Photo of Cara Muhlhahn, Certified Nurse Midwife (left) with Mayra and David Radzinski from Red Envelope Entertainment

December 21, 2007

Weekend's best bet: Sweeney Todd

sweeney.jpg

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help:

Sweeney Todd
Johnny Depp and Tim Burton team up with Stephen Sondheim for a deliciously morbid 'Sweeney Todd'. Read more...

Charlie Wilson's War
Tom Hanks is so revered in Hollywood, it's often hard to tell if "Charlie Wilson's War" is an homage to him or to his character, Charlie Wilson, a Texas Congressman who spearheaded a CIA covert operation to help Afghanistan wage and eventually win a war against the invading Soviets in the 1980s.Read more...

AP photo of Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter in Sweeney Todd from DreamWorks Pictures and Warner Bros. Pictures, by Leah Gallo

December 14, 2007

Weekend's best bet: I Am Legend, and Kite Runner

will.jpg

kite.jpg

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help:

I Am Legend
This elegant film seems to have been made for the express purpose of showing off a post-apocalyptic New York City -- and that's a good enough reason for us.Read more...

The Kite Runner
Adapted from the best-selling novel by Khaled Hosseini, "The Kite Runner" is about two boys growing up in Kabul, Afghanistan--and is earnest story rooted in deeply felt human emotions that's well worth your time (and movie dollars).Read more...

Youth Without Youth
You have to hand it to Francis Ford Coppola--who else would adapt a novella by a Romanian philosopher (Mircea Eliade) into a personal testament on mortality and spirituality? Read more...

Photo of Will Smith in I Am Legend from Warner Bros. Pictures.

Photo of Zekiria Ebrahimi in The Kite Runner by Phil Bray / Dreamworks

December 7, 2007

Weekend's best bet: Juno

juno.jpg

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help:

Juno
Jason Reitman strikes an easy balance between commercial appeal and indie refineness in "Juno."Read more...

Atonement
Atonement" is a hotbed of heartbreak and trauma, a sweeping love story with a mighty cruel edge starring Keira Knightley and James McAvoy. Yet when all is said and done, it's dissatisfying enough to make you want to read the book (if you haven't already), just to see how much better the story might be with the luxury of literary nuance. Read more...

The Golden Compass
Though it would not have been kind to the rumps of the restless kids who will be patronizing the film, New Line could have benefited from making "The Golden Compass" a little longer. Instead, director Chris Weitz, bound to the nomenclature of the expansive, fantastical universe of Philip Pullman's original novel, shoehorns in too many underdeveloped scenes and characters Read more...

Photo of Ellen Page and Michael Cera in Juno by Doane Gregory

November 30, 2007

Weekend's best bet: 'The Savages' and 'Diving Bell and the Butterfly'

film1.jpg

film2.jpg

Wondering which new release to check out this weekend? amNewYork movie critic Mina Hochberg is here to help--with two four-star films for the first time:

The Savages
After a season of such moribund movies, it's refreshing to see a film that treats mortality with a less heavy hand. "The Savages" offers some of the most heartfelt laughs of the year, and also some of the most heartbreaking moments..Read more...

The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
The true story of a French Vogue editor-- Jean-Dominique Bauby (Mathieu Amalric), who suffered a stroke and lost muscle control throughout his body, with the exception of his eyes--starts as a tale of unimaginable tragedy but quickly becomes a triumph of will. Read more...

AP Photo of Laura Linney and Philip Seymour Hoffman in "The Savages" provided by Twentieth Century Fox

AP Photo of Mathieu Amalric, right, and Max Von Sydow in a scene from "The
Diving Bell And The Butterfly" provided by Miramax Films

Video